Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., successfully forced a last-minute name change to President Donald Trump’s sweeping $3.3 trillion legislative package just before it passed the Senate — stripping it of its signature branding as the “One Big Beautiful Bill.”
While Sen. Pete Ricketts, R-Neb., was presiding over the chamber, Schumer raised a point of order targeting lines three to five on the bill’s first page, which read:
“SHORT TITLE. This Act may be cited as the ‘One Big Beautiful Bill Act.’”
Schumer argued the title violated Section 313 B1A of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, commonly known as the Byrd Rule, which bars “extraneous” provisions in reconciliation bills. Ricketts sustained the objection, effectively removing the name from the legislation.
“This is not a ‘big, beautiful bill’ at all,” Schumer told reporters afterward. “It’s now called ‘the act’ — but what it really is, is the ‘Big Ugly Betrayal,’ and the American people know it.”
Schumer didn’t hold back, warning that the bill’s impacts would be long-lasting and devastating:
“Tens of millions will lose health insurance. Millions of jobs will vanish. People will get sick and die. Kids will go hungry. And the national debt will explode to unprecedented levels.”
He went on to cite the retirement of Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., who announced he would not seek re-election rather than support what Schumer called a “catastrophic” vote for his constituents.
Asked whether he intended the name change to antagonize Trump, Schumer replied:
“I didn’t even think of Trump. I thought of the truth. If you lose your health insurance, if you lose your job in clean energy, or if you can’t feed your kid on $5 a day — there’s nothing ‘beautiful’ about that.”
Narrow Passage After All-Night Session
Despite fierce Democratic opposition, Trump’s bill passed the Senate early Tuesday morning in a 51-50 vote after an all-night vote-a-rama. Vice President JD Vance cast the tiebreaking vote.
Every Democrat voted against the bill, joined by Republicans Rand Paul (Ky.), Susan Collins (Maine), and Thom Tillis (N.C.).
Vance defended the package as a win for working Americans.
“Massive tax cuts, especially no tax on tips and overtime. And most importantly, big money for border security,” Vance posted on social media. “This is a big win for the American people.”
He also echoed comments made by longtime GOP strategist Roger Stone, who pushed back on concerns over the bill’s projected $3.3 trillion addition to the deficit:
“Federal revenues spiked after the 2017 Trump tax cuts, just like after Reagan and JFK,” Stone wrote. “The deficit is caused by overspending — which we’re addressing through rescission bills. And by the way, the CBO is always wrong.”
Progressives Cry Foul
Democrats were quick to condemn the bill’s passage.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., wrote on X:
“JD Vance was the deciding vote to cut Medicaid across the country. An absolute and utter betrayal of working families.”
Despite early hesitation, Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, ultimately backed the bill after GOP leaders included Alaska-specific carveouts to secure her vote.
What’s Next
The legislation now heads back to the House, where lawmakers must reconcile differences between the House and Senate versions — particularly around Medicaid provisions. Republican leaders are racing to finalize the bill and deliver it to President Trump’s desk by July 4.
If they succeed, the fireworks won’t just be in the sky — they’ll be on Capitol Hill, too.
Be First to Comment